Should Prisoners Be Allowed to Donate Organs? No!

Hello. I am Art Caplan, Langon Medical Center, New York University, Department of Medical Ethics.

Shallow executor should be allowed to donate organs at the time of executions? This problem has appeared many times. In a recent incident in Ohio, a man facing the execution ran out of his complaint and asked him to donate his organs to his mother and his sister. His sister is undergoing dialysis; his mother is having a heart attack. Other such incidents appear in Oregon

If our organs are very short and we are executing people, why do we say that we will not use the organs of these prisoners? Especially when prisoners themselves offer opportunities or ask questions they want to do, why are not we allowed to do this? Can we make some good ones from evil and misery?

By the way, Ohio POWs were sentenced to death for murder. He is an absolute evil and a bad person. The question of enabling the notion that prisoners admit donation of organs is whether they should do something that they can be regarded as heroes when they do bad, sneaky things .

In other words, if we punish people, some of the punishment is that they can not redeem themselves. Organ donation may be prohibited as it makes something worse, we will run in some states, it seems that he is not a bad person. If you like, this is a battle about punishment theory.

Prisons usually do not allow prisoners to donate organs to non-relatives. There are no laws concerning the provision of organs to prisoners, but due to concerns about the high risk environment of infectious diseases in prisons, the immigrant community has not recommended the use of prisoners' organs since the early 1990s. Doctors and ethicists also criticize this idea, especially if there is temptation to participate, because prisoners can not agree on procedures in a free and non-obligatory environment. However, as modern examinations progress to safely eliminate infectious diseases and to ensure that there is no motivation for participation, prisoners voluntarily undertake to allow prisoners to agree on general medical procedures I believe that you can agree to provide donation. Through cautious safety measures, there are more than two million prisoners in the United States who believe prisoners can provide solutions to reduce the organ deficiency in the United States.

However, Longo's efforts to donate organs again caused a debate about how to deal with prisoner's organ transplant. Prison rights advocacy groups and ethicalists are concerned about the consequences of forced donation and the fear of expanding diseases (including human immunodeficiency virus), and prisoners, especially those who are sentenced to death, make donations can do. "If you are a prisoner and you are in the row of death and you feel like donating a group of organs or organs instead of bringing it to the tomb, I will say 100%," Scott · King said. Computer sales engineers acquired kidneys from biological donors in 2001. "It is far better to live than to live, so if anyone wants to donate, I will do my best."