Responses to the Doctrine of Mind-Brain Identity

The pain corresponding to Mind Brain identity theory is, for example, the release of c-fibers in the central nervous system, or perhaps fibers; I think that broccoli merely kills you to make a human B (bk) - fiber Black well companion to philosophy, such as photography that believes: Chapter 5 William G. Lycan's "psychology of mind" As its name implies, the theory or doctrine of mind and brain identity is the idea and the brain Consciousness and problem) of dualism. material

Psychological identity theory thinks that the state and process of the mind is the same as the state and process of the brain. Strictly speaking, you do not have to think that your heart is exactly the same as your brain. In idioms we used exchangeable words "she has a good heart" and "she has a good brain", but 'her weight is 50 ounces' I can not say. Here we recognize thinking and the process of recognition of the brain, and the state of the mind and brain. Let's think about the painful experience of watching something or having a psychological image. Psychological identity theory thinks that these experiences are only brain processes, not just brain processes.

Mind knows where the mind is, and in addition to the brain it has its own unique identity. The brain is a material habitat of the mind, but the idea of ​​living and living in the house is not important. If we can compare the brain with the computer, the brain can be regarded as its operator. A clever idea is born when the heart manipulates the computer's brain. Even though the brains of the two substances are 100%, the ideas generated by them are not the same if different ideas act on them.

Most dualists believe that the soul is the same as the mind, but it differs from the brain and its function. In dualismists, we believe that the brain is a new attribute of the brain: it depends on the brain, but it is not the same as the brain and its process. This position is often referred to as "property dualism", but here we are interested in material dualism, that is, the theory that the mind is an independent matter (not just another property), so it is physically There may be death (Swinburn, 1997)