Do Sources Suggest That Haig Uncaring and Sacrificed the Lives of His Soldiers For No Reason?

In this article we show that all sources of the booklet support Haig's assertion that soldier's life is being sacrificed without any reason or reason. I will give you a balanced answer, show two views, and make a decision. Source A supports this argument. Because it uses the cold and harsh condition like the loss of a soldier "teaching" the country about the reality of war. When he knows that many soldiers will die, he thinks that "seriously injured list" is inevitable because he attacks and we can guess that he is cold without concern for the soldier's life It seems to be.

Another reason why Hyig is depicted as a butcher is his obviously indifferent and rude manner of soldiers. This view was told in Source 8, "His people live in a muddy and noisy entrenchment", they said "they sleep in a comfortable bed of quiet country houses and eat the best dish," I told you. Another cross analysis of source 11 described the harsh living conditions of solder horribly. They are "smell, jagged, unshaved, insomnia", which is a good example of how bad and stunning the condition in the trench is.

Source A deals with casualties of the next Somme campaign in a statement written by Haig. As Haig himself wrote, this source deliberately will not attempt to condemn his own leadership and strategy. Instead, it provides insight into the feelings of Higg when planning the battle of Somme. According to his explanation, he felt great losses inevitable, which indicates that he is ready to accept high victims. However, according to sources, he believes that "high level commanders do not have much skills" can prevent these losses, though he thinks casualties are inevitable There is no other strategy that can stop it. This source supports this statement as Hagrid sacrificed his life. The word "sacrifice" is also mentioned in excerpts to explain inevitable losses.