Critical Analysis of Peter Coclanis’ Article: Atlantic World or Atlantic/World?

"The Atlantic world is the world of Europe, Africa and America", they are "made together" - not made by anyone. This is a professor of history and economics at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, a belief of Peter Kokranis, associate professor of international affairs. In his thesis: Atlantic World or Atlantic / World. Coclanis announced to William and Mary Quarterly in 2006, and he believes that research in Atlantic history is too narrow. He writes in this article that there is no background to completely separating the interaction between the Atlantic world and other worlds.

As Coclanis's paper quoted above shows, the need to adopt a global perspective rather than the Atlantic is primarily to study currency flow, Asian business, and work in the Pacific Rim. Dennis O. Flynn's article in his book and a series of other books and articles strongly demonstrates that China's demand for silver creates a world economy integrated into the Atlantic and the Pacific. In addition to the above work by Dermigny and Wills on Chinese business and products, there were many recent quantities confirming the scale, appeal and complexity of production in China, India and Southeast Asia from 1500 to 1800. We have a lot. Kenneth Pomeranz and Steven Topik, The World of Trade Creation: Society, Culture and the World Economy: From 1400 to the present (Armonk, New York State: M. E. Sharpe, 1999)

The books and articles cited in this section introduce the concepts and methods of the Atlantic world and recent discussions on the limitations of this term. As the concept shows, some of the more powerful criticisms of the Atlantic approach oppose the term "Atlantic world" and have a very exclusive tendency. Among them, it has a European impulse to the institutions of African and American Indians, which substitutes for the British colonial North American history (reflecting the academic focus of many early supporters of Atlantic history) have become. Phenomenon A series of major journals dedicated to academic forums recently discussed the usefulness and limitations of the term and the relationship between other historical approaches and historical approaches (see Oxford Bibliographic Online Articles Atlantic History). Games etc. Klooster 2009 provides comparative study of the Atlantic Revolution