Can You Be Good Without God?

The "Times" blogger on philosophy believes that being an atheist does not mean "everything happens" - in reality it is reversed. What do you think? Is morality independent of God? Are those people who do not believe in God as good as those still? What determines your decision to act ethically, and how to do it yourself?

I think many people think that atheism means nihilism - rejecting God means rejecting morality. They deduce that people who deny God must be indifferent at least in consideration of right and wrong, even though they are not aggressive evil.

Only morality is independent of God, and we can get a sense of morality from religious worship. Only morality is independent from God and anyone can have a moral foundation that supports God's order. Let's explain why. First of all, let's quietly look at the influence of having morally minded on the existence of God. Please consider the following moral decisions - in my opinion, the judgment is clearly correct.

These specific moral decisions are not true unless morality rests on the existence of God, that is, God does not exist. In my opinion, this is a special proposition. If God does not exist - then does slavery become an Englishman? Is there any problem with torture? What does the pain of others say?

Now think about our personal relationship - how do we love our parents, children, our life partner, our friends. The moral values ​​of these people depend on the existence of God, meaning that these people themselves are worthless. Their boat or their car. In other words, the historical connection we cherish, the character and personality character we love is that it is useless on its own.

Student: Please read Anthony's post and tell me what you think about this complex topic. Where does morality come from? What leads you to think about actions? Do you choose ethical behavior? Mainly due to the commitment of rewards or the threat of punishment - from God or other authorities? If you are an atheist, if you do something that you can express morally, God can oppose you as opposed to thinking that living your life in a moral way is more important You can forgive, this is the only value in your life. What is your choice?

Please give the following comments to the students aged 13 and older. Please use only your name. For reasons of privacy policy, students' comments will not be posted using the last name.

One day I realized that Freethinkers used a new slogan to print a poster. Of course, not all atheists are liars, thieves, murderers. On the contrary, many people are very happy people. But at a deeper level, the slogan destroyed itself. So I went to the table and began discussing this with Freethinkers. I claimed that it is impossible to do good without God.

When you believe in God, you also believe that God is good. This is the start of discussion. God is just kind and can only decide what is good. Julia Carter, professor of philosophy at Dartmouth College, said in her book "Ethics", "The central idea behind the theory of God's will as a moral foundation is this is God's will Only if God orders it, "You must accept God, when you do this, he will guide you through the Holy Spirit just to do the right thing But what will happen if it does not work? Simplicity: We have not obeyed God's instructions and orders, God leads us to choose good things, but also gives us the ability to make choices This explains why we sometimes make the wrong choice, but we can not blame God with the wrong choice.This is our responsibility, so we are You must approach the God for gas. Well, good morals come from him

Plato raised the following dilemma in his dialogue Euthyphro. "Is God so advantageous as it is a good thing or a good thing, is there a benefit that God ordered?" (4) If it is the beginning, since morality is not objective in God Dr. Craig is denied. Arguments or second, morality depends on God, ie subjective morality. In any case, this dilemma at least reasonably doubts the first premise and can at best deny it at best. It is unfair to continue if Dr. Craig is not allowed to deal with this dilemma.