Blaming Haig for the Slaughter of the Somme

Blaming the killing of Haig of Somme Source A is a well-balanced source. It comes from a book called Marshal Hagrid, written by historian Philipp Warner in 1991, which arises from secondary evidence as it was written after the war. It includes professional Haig and anti Haig parts. "If the standard for a successful generals is to win the war, you have to decide whether Haig was successful." This statement said that he succeeded in winning the war Praise the generals of Haig.

"On April 11, 1918, Douglas The Hague won all ranks in all the units of France and Flanders." Youth Bella Britain re-announced. (London: Penguin Classics, 2005), p. In order to be accused of slaughtering Som, Hagrid was recently restored as William Bradport 's blood victory "The Winner of the War": the Sacrifice of Somme and the Construction of the 20th Century (London: Small, 2009 Year) and J. P. Douglas The Hague of Harris and the First World War (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009). But neither of these books completely excludes that Haig holds his strategy, personality, ability, politics and personal beliefs.

Source B is an account written by Haig, indicating that the first day of Somme succeeded. An excerpt written before the start of Somme expressed Haig 's optimism about future fighting. This shows that he believes that despite the hope of victory, contrary to the view he did about the flawed strategy, he prove that his strategy will succeed. Haig also solved the problem of morale, said his officials and executives are full of confidence in the next battle. This shows that Haig highly appreciates the importance of morale and suggests that he care about the welfare of his people. The second excerpt from this source was written by Haig after the first day of Somme. This seems to corroborate his expectation for the success of his plan and tells that Somme's first day is a convincing victory. Information source B may be attributed to deliberately distorted reports provided to Haig, often to maintain an unstable mood